American Idol - Top 12

I almost nailed it. I was wrong on 2, and they were ones I struggled with.

I couldn't quite pinpoint which would leave - Gedeon or Kevin, and Melissa or Ayla. Honestly, I thought Melissa should have gone first, but there's always next week.

I am a true American Idol geek.

Current favorites - Chris, Taylor, Katharine and Mandisa.